You’ve heard it. Those dangerous words: “Lower your standards… you’re too picky.” Probably from the sweet, well-meaning woman in your church kitchen who found her husband when times (and expectations) were... different. Her advice starts and ends with, “Just find a Christian!”

We are accused of being ‘picky’ to shame us into settling.

But here’s the truth: God is picky. He invented standards! The entire biblical narrative is the story of a God who sets a high bar—for holiness, for covenant, for love—and then provides the grace to meet it.

The real question isn’t if you should have standards… but which ones are essential, which are wise, and which are just foolish walls you built yourself.

This isn’t a theoretical debate - we see the frustration boiling over online. A viral Reddit thread titled, “Gentleman, you are allowed to have standards,” captured it perfectly. The original poster nailed the core issue:

It’s time to stop defending our standards and start defining them correctly. Here’s a clear, biblical framework:

We’ve all heard the cliché: “If you’re both Christians, that’s all that matters.”

Tell that to the “Christian couples” living lives of quiet desperation, or the ones filling out divorce papers. This is a half-truth, and half-truths are whole lies.

Shared faith is the floor, not the ceiling. It’s the foundation you build upon, & not the finished house.

That said, whether or not to have the foundation isn’t up for debate. Being a genuine, active Christ-follower who’s growing spiritually and bearing fruit is a definite non-negotiable.

Never, ever compromise on this. Dating a non-Christian who merely ‘tolerates’ your faith isn’t building on a shaky foundation; it’s building on sand.

No amount of chemistry or shared hobbies can compensate for a missing foundation.

This is where people start calling you “picky.”

These standards aren’t explicitly commanded in Scripture, but they are crucial for building a peaceful, friction-free life. They are the walls, the plumbing, the electrical wiring of your future marriage. Ignoring them isn’t faith; it’s foolishness.

He is a Christian, just like you. But he wants five kids while you want zero. He blows up during conflicts, bleeding on those who didn’t cut him. Or he’s called to a remote mission field, while you are called to serve where you’re planted.

While these aren’t Tier 1 “foundational” differences, they are still blueprints for misery. You’re both just wrong for each other.

This tier is also where we tackle the tricky question of spiritual maturity.

“He’s a great guy, but he’s not as mature a Christian as I am. Is that a red flag?”

The answer lies in trajectory, not position. Show him grace if he is a God-fearing believer headed in the same direction as you, even if he’s a couple of steps behind. But it’s a red flag if he is spiritually stagnant, complacent, or resistant to growth.

This is where we get to the fun stuff—the “shallow” deal-breakers we’re often afraid to admit. ‘She can’t be a Swiftie. He must be over 6 feet. She must be a “trad wife.”’

Here’s the rule: Hold these loosely.

These are the throw pillows of your relationship. They make things comfortable, but they won’t hold up the roof. The problem comes when you reject a perfectly solid, Tier-1-and-2-aligned person because his throw pillows are beige and you wanted turquoise.

Ask yourself: Why is this a deal-breaker? A comment in that Reddit thread offered a common-sense piece of self-awareness: “As long as you meet or exceed the standard you have for your partner, I think it’s fair game.”

So, be honest.
Do you need him to be 6 feet because you’re 5’10”? Do you want to be a stay-at-home mom because you want to protect your children from a brainwashing worldly school system? Those are specific, justifiable needs.

But are you a 4’11” woman rejecting all godly men under six feet? A 42-year-old man insisting on a wife under 30? That’s not a preference; that’s a prison of your own making.

So are you being too picky?

If you’re allowing Tier 3 preferences to veto a candidate who solidly meets Tiers 1 and 2, then yes. You are rejecting prime real estate over the paint color.

But if you’re being called ‘picky’ for holding firm to your Tier 1 and 2 standards, then no -you’re being discerning. And saving yourself from a lifetime of regret.

Stop defending your pickiness. Stop lowering your standards. Start right-sizing them according to this biblical framework

In a world that settles for less, being ‘picky’ about the things God is ‘picky’ about - is just smart!