She Didn’t See It Coming. But The Signs Were Always There.

Lisa called her mom around 7 that evening sounding happy.

She was celebrating her first Christmas Eve with her new husband. Lobster dinner, champagne and all.

By midnight, she was dead.

By 5 a.m., her body was wrapped in garbage bags and dumped in a frozen field in Huntington, New York.

And the man who put her there was already in front of cameras - crying, pleading, begging the public to help find his “missing” wife.

Handsome. Wealthy. Charming. Great with parents. Perfect in public. But a monster behind closed doors.

That’s the terrifying thing about dangerous men. They don’t look dangerous.

This is not just a true crime story.

It’s an autopsy of the blind spots, the filters that distort reality, and the lies we tell ourselves that make red flags seem less red.

If you’re dating, engaged, or even just entertaining the idea of a relationship - keep reading. This one’s for you.

Lisa Weaver grew up in Queens, New York. Bright, athletic, ambitious — already a loan officer at a Long Island bank by her early twenties.

She had people. Parents who loved her fiercely. An uncle who would walk through fire for her. Cousins and friends who would later spend freezing nights searching Huntington’s streets looking for her. She wasn’t invisible. She wasn’t unloved.

Then she met Matthew Solomon.

Broad shoulders. Steelworker. Magnum P.I. mustache. Completely obsessed with her.

Behind him stood the Solomon family: respectable, established, powerful. His dad, Jack Solomon, was a decorated war hero and wealthy banker. His mother Ruth — soft-spoken, always smiling, the picture of a devoted wife.

From the outside, this looked like the kind of family people dream about marrying into.

And this wasn’t some whirlwind romance either. Lisa dated Matthew Solomon for four years. Then in October of ‘87, Lisa Weaver became Lisa Solomon.

Six weeks later, she was gone.

Here’s the hard truth. Seeing red flags is easy.

Seeing them and actually leaving before it’s too late? That’s something else entirely

Women are human. There are filters - built from money, status, fear, and control - that distort what they’re looking at. And they make red look like orange. Orange starts looking yellow. And eventually it’s basically normal.

So let’s talk about the filters. One by one.

Matthew Solomon wasn’t just a good-looking guy. He came with money. Real money.

His father, Jack, had amassed serious wealth in banking. When Matthew was arrested, Jack paid over $110,000 upfront to assemble the best legal defense team money could buy. That's roughly $300,000 today.

That kind of money opened doors, closed mouth, buys reputation. buys the feeling that this family is untouchable.

And for a young woman from a modest background, marrying into that world can feel like finally landing somewhere solid. It wasn’t solid. It just looked solid.

The money filter is one of the oldest traps in human history. And people still fall for it every day.

Wealth, status, lifestyle, a powerful last name — none of those things are substitutes for character or the fear of God.

CTA: When you catch yourself thinking “but his family is so established” STOP. Ask: What does he look like when money can’t fix the situation?

There’s a question underneath this entire story that almost nobody asks: What kind of man raised Matthew Solomon?

Because we got a glimpse.

After Matthew was convicted of murder, Jack stood up in that courtroom and screamed obscenities at Lisa's grieving mother

And here’s the doozy. And Matthew himself admitted his father was a monster at home. Verbally and physically abusive towards wife and children. He demanded absolute servitude - and got it.. Ruth endured it quietly, hid it behind a smile, and called it marriage.

Was God in that home? Was Jack Solomon a God-fearing man? Was he kind to women? And what do you think he passed on to his son?

Snakes birth snakes, not sweet puppies. Matthew walked in his father’s footsteps. And Lisa paid the price.

CTA: Before you study the man, study his father (or the men that raised him). This is a non negotiable.

Matthew tracked every one of Lisa’s movements.

He needed to know where she was, who she was texting, who she was talking to. He even accompanied her to the bathroom and waited outside the door.

He picked out her clothes. He slowly cut her off from friends, family, and support systems - because they were “bad influences” on her.

Read that paragraph again.

Because here’s the thing about control: it starts small and looks harmless.

At first it feels protective. Attentive. Intense, kinda love. And you tell yourself:
“He just wants to know I’m safe.” “He worries about me.” “He loves me.”

Like fog, it rolls in gradually. Quietly. Until one day it’s everywhere.

And by the time you finally recognize the coercive control, he already owns you. And now leaving feels impossible

CTA: The big question is not "is he controlling?" The question is: “is my freedom getting bigger or shrinking?

Matthew had a short-fuse.

Lisa knew - she was on the receiving end of his abuse for four years.

She had the bruises to prove it. And she hid them — from her family, from her friends - because she, like Matthew’s mom, believed her job was to protect and maintain the family’s reputation.

For six days after Lisa’s death, he played the devastated husband with Oscar-worthy performance. Handwritten letters. Tearful press conferences. He walked in the search parties. He fooled everyone. Including Lisa’s own mother.

The “Matthew Solomon” the public saw and the one Lisa lived with were two completely different people.

CTA: Does everyone thinks he’s amazing - but you see the “ugly side” of him behind closed doors?

That gap between the public version and the private one is not a quirk. It’s a massive red flag - hiding in plain sight.

A few days before the wedding, Lisa’s mother arranged a psychic reading for her daughter. And even after Lisa disappeared, psychics were added to the search team.

Lisa and her family were not Bible-believing Christians. They probably did not know Deuteronomy 18:10–12. But they were desperate — and in their desperation, they trusted mediums instead of seeking God. And they had no one speaking biblical truth or seeking God’s wisdom as this entire situation unfolded.

One of the worst decisions you will ever make is dating or marrying someone who is unequally yoked - an unbeliever.

You cannot - and should not - trust a man who does not know and fear God.

Sounds like judgment. But that’s protection.

Lisa’s uncle - Howard Klerk - the closest thing she had to a father figure, was convinced that Matthew was not the right one for her.

He took her into his home for an entire week and pleaded with her to call off the wedding.

Lisa heard every word, didn’t budge… and went through with the wedding.

CTA: When the people who love you — the ones with no hidden agenda, who only want your good — say, “Please don’t do this,” listen.

Ask why.

Do not rationalize it away. Listen to their wisdom.

Lisa knew exactly who Matthew Solomon was.

The control. The temper. The bruises. The manipulation. The family dysfunction. She saw the red flags. All of them. And she said yes anyway.

Maybe it was the money.
Maybe it was Jack.
Maybe she believed she could change him.
Maybe she felt it was safer to marry than not.
Maybe it was all of it at once.

We’ll never know.

But her story matters because somewhere reading this is a woman in a relationship who sees the red flags and is slowly explaining them away.

So here’s the final take away.

As Christians, We do not have to turn to psychics, mediums, or “the universe” for guidance. We are children of the living God.

So, “Trust in the Lord with all your heart. Lean not on your own understanding. In all your ways acknowledge Him — and He shall direct your paths.” — Proverbs 3:5–6

Even in this.

Especially in this.

For more articles and biblical insight on dating, marriage, and relationships for Christian professionals, subscribe to The Equally Yoked at

https://www.theequallyyoked.com