It sounds like the setup for a Pureflix drama. She loves Jesus. He doesn’t believe in Him.
They’ve known each other for years, the chemistry is undeniable, but now she’s stuck in a catch-22—obey God or follow her heart.
Only, this isn’t fiction. It’s the real story of a young woman who shared her dilemma online:
She [29F] has known him [32M] for 15 years. He’s smart, kind, funny, and—oh yeah—an atheist. They were friends in college, lost touch, and reconnected after nearly a decade.
She’s four years into her walk with Christ, praying for a godly husband. But when they met again, the spark was instant—and let’s just say the boundaries didn’t exactly hold.
Now she can’t get him out of her head. She’s torn between what her heart craves and what Scripture clearly says in 2 Corinthians 6:14
So she asked the internet: “Where do I go from here?”
What the Crowd Said
One thing about the internet—you’ll never be short on opinions. But some of these were worth listening to:
1. The Voice of Experience:
“Please don’t. You’ll be spiritually isolating yourself… disagreements will come, and little by little you’ll backslide until you find yourself far, far away from Christ.” — dangovy
2. Listen to God’s Word, Not Your Emotions
“If you want to obey God & take the guidance of Scripture seriously, then communicate that to him. Don’t normalize this relationship - or justify it by equating it with your family and friends” — Broly
3. The Harsh Realist:
“Run! I married a non-Christian. He changed my life. I’m now an ex-Christian”
4. The Evangelist
“Share the Gospel. Let him choose / make the decision. If he rejects Christ, you reject him. Bitter pill, but that’s the deal.”
Strangers on the internet aren’t always wise. But here, the chorus was consistent: Don’t lean on chemistry. Lean on Christ.
What Scripture Says
The Bible isn’t unclear about this. In 2 Corinthians 6, Paul paints a vivid picture:
“Do not be unequally yoked with unbelievers. For what fellowship has light with darkness?”
Now, a yoke isn’t some spiritual handcuff —it’s farming gear. Two oxen pulling one plow. If one pulls north and the other south, you don’t make progress. You just carve circles in the dirt.
Same with marriage. You may start out madly in love, but nothing wears you out like trying to drag someone toward Jesus who has both heels dug in.
Sparks vs. Substance
Is it possible to love someone who doesn’t share your faith? Of course—it happens all the time. But the real question isn’t, “Can you date an atheist?” It’s, Should you —- should you risk your walk with Christ—your eternity—for someone who loves you, but rejects your Savior?”
The woman who shared her story admitted: “I’ve dated Christian men for two years and felt no spark. But with him… it’s different. And yes, sparks are fun, powerful and intoxicating. But a tug-of-war between Christ and compromise always ends the same way: with regret.
A Final Word
Let him wrestle with Christ. Share the Gospel, invite him to church, pray for his salvation and share resources—Lee Strobel’s The Case for Christ or one of Greg Laurie’s evangelistic sermons, etc. BUT do not chain your future to someone running the opposite way.
The Bible doesn’t say, “never love unbelievers.” We’re called to love them enough to point them to Christ. But in dating and marriage, the call is clear: yoke only with someone running toward heaven—just like you.
Thanks for reading The Equally Yoked! This post is public so feel free to share it.
Or get it by email here.
